Myth Commentaries/2014515/4 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.258.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis was well done. Much of the focus was on similarities among the versions of the flood story%2C so more investigation of the significance of differences among the stories would be helpful. May 25, 2014 19:57
Myth Commentaries/2014516/3 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.261.1)  Vote Accept - This is well done%2C particularly your emphasis on how divine roles differ in each of the accounts of the flood%2C as when Deucalion and Pyrrha appear to survive by good fortune%2C even though they are apparently quite pious. May 25, 2014 20:02
Myth Commentaries/2014517/2 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.274.1)  Vote Accept - Good discussion of the different roles of various deities and divine forces in bringing about the flood. This is a common theme in Greek and Roman myths%2C that gods in charge of different spheres can assist or conflict with one another. May 25, 2014 20:05
Myth Commentaries/2014514/15 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.250.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent%2C detailed analysis of the three different versions of the flood account. In the future%2C it would be helpful to have some consideration of the significance of differences %28and similarities%29 among versions of a myth%2C as well. May 25, 2014 20:12
Myth Commentaries/2014517/8 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.280.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis points out a few similarities and differences among the versions of the myth%2C but it doesn%27t go into much depth%2C particularly with respect to the significance of each version%3A why does it matter that Zeus has to obey the rulings of fate concerning the end of the world%2C for example%3F May 25, 2014 20:17
Myth Commentaries/2014517/1 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.273.1)  Vote Accept - Good analysis%2C particularly your discussion of Jupiter%27s limitations with respect to destroying the human race on earth. Is this significant in light of the fact that Ovid%27s Jupiter seems to call on aid from other sources to send the flood itself%3F May 25, 2014 21:03
Myth Commentaries/2014516/6 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.264.1)  Vote Accept - Well done%2C especially the discussion of the differing roles of the gods in each version of the myth. One point that would be worth developing%3A how exactly is Jupiter%27s role in the Roman version of the myth different from that of the Judeo-Christian God%2C and what is the significance of this%3F May 25, 2014 21:07
Myth Commentaries/2014518/5 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.288.1)  Vote Accept - Very good discussion of the similarities and differences among the versions of the flood narrative. What is the significance Jupiter%27s limited role in his choice of how to destroy humanity%2C and his limited role in bringing about the flood itself%3F May 25, 2014 21:11
Myth Commentaries/2014517/5 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.277.1)  Vote Accept - Good discussion of the different versions of the myths%2C especially the number of deities mentioned in Ovid that play different roles in bringing about the flood and assisting Deucalion and Pyrrha afterwards. May 26, 2014 00:13
Myth Commentaries/2014518/8 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.291.1)  Vote Accept - Good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. More discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful%2C as when Deucalion and Pyrrha seem to be saved by luck%2C rather than Jupiter%27s intention from the beginning. May 26, 2014 00:19
Myth Commentaries/2014518/15 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.298.1)  Vote Accept - Good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. Note that in Pindar%2C the gods are not called %22evil%22%2C but Pindar warns his listeners not to speak evil things about the gods. May 26, 2014 00:22
Myth Commentaries/2014518/18 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.301.1)  Vote Accept - Good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. More discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful%3A why does it matter that Jupiter in Ovid%27s account doesn%27t give direct orders to Deucalion and Pyrrha to build a ship to survive the flood%3F May 26, 2014 00:25
Myth Commentaries/2014516/1 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.259.1)  Vote Accept - Good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. What could be the significance of the sacrifices offered to deities after the flood in each account%3F May 26, 2014 00:28
Myth Commentaries/2014519/9 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.311.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 00:32
Myth Commentaries/2014519/12 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.314.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 00:34
Myth Commentaries/2014518/16 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.299.1)  Vote Accept - A very good analysis that compares and contrasts different versions of the myth in detail. Particularly perceptive is your description of Jupiter%27s %22chain of command%22 in Ovid%27s account%2C as well as Deucalion and Pyrrha%27s cleverness in solving the riddle of the oracle. May 26, 2014 00:39
Myth Commentaries/2014518/11 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.294.1)  Vote Accept - Very good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. More discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful. Remember that next time you can include your analysis of all texts for commentary in one submission%2C but for now%2C the separate submissions are just fine. May 26, 2014 00:42
Myth Commentaries/2014519/14 (2014/05/19-11.06.28) (cite/perseus/mythcomm.316.1)  Vote Accept - Very good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. More discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful. Remember that next time you can include your analysis of all texts for commentary in one submission%2C but for now%2C the separate submissions are just fine. May 26, 2014 00:42
Myth Commentaries/2014519/21 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.329.1)  Vote Accept - Very good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. More discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful. Remember that next time you can include your analysis of all texts for commentary in one submission%2C but for now%2C the separate submissions are just fine. May 26, 2014 00:43
Myth Commentaries/2014519/22 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.330.1)  Vote Accept - Very good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. More discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful. Remember that next time you can include your analysis of all texts for commentary in one submission%2C but for now%2C the separate submissions are just fine. May 26, 2014 00:44
Myth Commentaries/2014518/17 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.300.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths %28e.g. polytheistic vs. monotheistic religious views affecting the roles of deities in the myths%29. May 26, 2014 00:51
Myth Commentaries/2014512/11 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.210.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 00:55
Myth Commentaries/2014518/13 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.296.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 00:57
Myth Commentaries/2014519/21 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.323.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 00:58
Myth Commentaries/2014519/22 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.324.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C particularly in analyzing the style of the authors. There could be a bit more discussion of the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 01:00
Myth Commentaries/2014519/17 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.319.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis compared and contrasted the various versions of the flood account%2C but was rather brief and could go into a more detailed discussion of the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:09
Myth Commentaries/2014519/16 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.318.1)  Vote Accept - Very good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. More discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful. May 26, 2014 02:11
Myth Commentaries/2014519/24 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.332.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:13
Myth Commentaries/2014519/25 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.333.1)  Vote Accept - Very good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. The use of repetition in Genesis and in other narratives coming from an oral tradition can add emphasis because recurring phrases would receive the most attention from the listener%2C and would be less likely to be forgotten. May 26, 2014 02:17
Myth Commentaries/2014519/3 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.305.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:19
Myth Commentaries/2014519/29 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.337.1)  Vote Accept - This is a good analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:21
Myth Commentaries/2014519/5 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.307.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:23
Myth Commentaries/2014519/20 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.322.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:24
Myth Commentaries/2014519/32 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.340.1)  Vote Accept - This is a good analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:25
Myth Commentaries/2014516/2 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.260.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:27
Myth Commentaries/2014519/28 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.336.1)  Vote Accept - Good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. More discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful. May 26, 2014 02:30
Myth Commentaries/2014519/36 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.344.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives as well as the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. There could be a bit more attention to detail%2C stating exactly what elements in the narratives are the same or differ %28for example%2C Noah is commanded to save animals%2C as well%29%2C but on the whole%2C very well done. May 26, 2014 02:34
Myth Commentaries/2014519/23 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.325.1)  Vote Accept - This is a very good analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:35
Myth Commentaries/2014519/43 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.351.1)  Vote Accept - This is a very good analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths.%0D%0A%0D%0A May 26, 2014 02:36
Myth Commentaries/2014519/6 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.308.1)  Vote Reject - Was there another submission of your assignment%3F May 26, 2014 02:38
Myth Commentaries/2014524/8 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.379.1)  Vote Reject - The text box here is empty%3B could you be sure to save your assignment before submitting to the board%3F If you continue to have trouble%2C please send me your assignments as email attachments. Thank you%21 May 26, 2014 02:39
Myth Commentaries/2014517/6 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.278.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis did well in comparing and contrasting the various versions of the flood account%2C but was rather brief and could go into a more detailed discussion of the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:40
Myth Commentaries/2014519/33 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.341.1)  Vote Reject - I have marked your other submission%2C since this one is empty. May 26, 2014 02:41
Myth Commentaries/2014519/44 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.352.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis did well in comparing and contrasting the various versions of the flood account%2C but was rather brief and could go into a more detailed discussion of the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:42
Myth Commentaries/2014519/46 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.354.1)  Vote Accept - Good discussion of the similarities and differences between the various versions of the flood account. A bit more discussion of the significance of differing elements in the myths would be helpful. Note in your last sentence that Noah%27s account is from monotheistic perspective%2C so that only one deity is at work in the narrative. May 26, 2014 02:44
Myth Commentaries/2014519/49 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.357.1)  Vote Accept - This is good analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives %28although it could go into a bit more detail%29%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:47
Myth Commentaries/2014519/19 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.321.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis was well done. Much of the focus was on similarities among the versions of the flood story%2C so more investigation of the significance of differences among the stories would be helpful. May 26, 2014 02:49
Myth Commentaries/2014519/45 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.353.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. Also%2C for this assignment it is not necessary to cite the sources%2C since they are limited and the same for the whole class%2C but that is certainly a very good instinct and should be done in academic essays. May 26, 2014 02:51
Myth Commentaries/2014519/1 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.303.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis compared and contrasted the various versions of the flood account%2C but was rather brief and could go into a more detailed discussion of the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:56
Myth Commentaries/2014519/41 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.349.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis compared and contrasted the various versions of the flood account%2C but was rather brief and could go into a more detailed discussion of the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:57
Myth Commentaries/2014519/38 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.346.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 02:58
Myth Commentaries/2014519/51 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.359.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. Also%2C please write in sentences rather than outline form in future assignments. May 26, 2014 02:59
Myth Commentaries/2014519/52 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.360.1)  Vote Accept - This is a good analysis that compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail and the original texts%2C but could discuss a bit more the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths. May 26, 2014 03:01
Myth Commentaries/2014519/42 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.350.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis was well done. Much of the focus was on similarities among the versions of the flood story%2C so more investigation of the significance of differences among the stories would be helpful. May 26, 2014 03:02
Myth Commentaries/2014519/31 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.339.1)  Vote Accept - This assignment is empty. May 26, 2014 03:03
Myth Commentaries/2014519/30 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.338.1)  Vote Accept - This is an excellent analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths.%0D%0A%0D%0A May 26, 2014 03:04
Myth Commentaries/2014519/11 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.313.1)  Vote Reject - This assignment is empty%3B please resubmit%2C and be sure to save before submission. May 26, 2014 03:05
Myth Commentaries/2014516/13 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.272.1)  Vote Accept - This is a good analysis that not only compares and contrasts the versions of the flood narratives with attention to detail%2C but also discusses the significance of the similarities and differences for our understanding of the myths.%0D%0A%0D%0A May 26, 2014 03:06
Myth Commentaries/2014518/12 (cite/perseus/mythcomm.295.1)  Vote Accept - This analysis is good%3B much of the focus was on comparing and contrasting the versions of the flood story%2C so more investigation of the significance of similarities and differences among the stories would be helpful. May 26, 2014 13:54

Myth Commentaries/2014516/8 (submitted)   done May 16, 2014 17:15